New York is one of the most regulated health insurance markets in the country. Community rating rules, guaranteed issue requirements, and an active state exchange make ACA plans more competitive here than almost anywhere else. That said, health sharing plans do operate in New York — legally — and for some residents they still make financial sense.

Here's what you actually need to know before signing up.

How Health Sharing Works Legally in New York

New York heavily regulates insurance companies. But health sharing plans aren't insurance — they're membership organizations where members voluntarily share medical costs. This distinction matters legally.

Health sharing plans operate under a federal exemption that predates the ACA. As long as they meet certain criteria (membership-based, voluntary cost-sharing, typically religious in nature), they can operate in any state, including New York, without being subject to state insurance regulations.

What this means for you: health sharing plans in New York are not regulated by the New York Department of Financial Services. If a claim gets denied, you can't file a complaint with the state insurance commissioner the way you could with a traditional insurer. Your recourse is internal appeals and, ultimately, the courts.

What's Available in New York

All of the major health sharing plans operate in New York:

| Plan | Monthly Cost (Individual, age 35) | Faith Required | Pre-Existing Wait | |------|----------------------------------|----------------|------------------| | CrowdHealth | ~$140 | No | None | | Zion HealthShare | $185–$268 | No | None | | Medi-Share | $227–$405 | Yes | 12 months | | Sedera | $199–$379 | No | Varies | | Samaritan Ministries | $220–$495 | Yes | 12–24 months |

Presidio Healthcare (Texas-only) is not available in New York.

The ACA Comparison in New York

Here's where New York is genuinely different from most states: ACA plans are often more competitive here.

New York uses community rating, which means insurers can't charge older residents more than younger ones (unlike most states, where premiums can be 3x higher at 60 than 30). This significantly reduces premiums for older New Yorkers.

For a 35-year-old in NYC making $60,000/year:

• ACA Silver (unsubsidized): ~$520/month
• Zion Standard: $215/month
• Savings with Zion: $3,660/year

For the same person making $40,000/year (qualifies for subsidies):

• ACA Silver with subsidy: ~$120–$200/month
• Zion Standard: $215/month
• ACA wins

For a 55-year-old in NYC (community rating advantage):

• ACA Silver: ~$560/month (community rating keeps this relatively flat)
• Zion: ~$350/month (health sharing does charge more for age)
• Savings with Zion: $2,520/year — but narrower than in states where ACA charges more for age

Run the subsidy math first. If you qualify for meaningful ACA subsidies in New York, ACA often beats health sharing on total cost.

When Health Sharing Makes Sense in New York

Despite New York's strong ACA market, health sharing still makes sense in certain situations:

High earners above subsidy thresholds: If your income is above 400% of the federal poverty level (~$58,320 for a single person), you don't qualify for ACA subsidies. At that income, unsubsidized ACA Silver in NYC runs $500-600/month. Zion at $215-268/month saves you $2,800-$4,600/year.

Healthy self-employed New Yorkers: Freelancers, consultants, and gig workers who are healthy and rarely need care get the most value from health sharing's lower premiums.

Those who don't qualify for Medicaid but can't afford ACA: New York expanded Medicaid generously, but there's still a gap for some residents. Health sharing can serve as coverage in the interim.

Provider Access in New York

This is important in a state with complex hospital networks:

Zion (Cigna PPO): Cigna's network in New York is strong — it includes NYU Langone, Mount Sinai, Northwell Health, and most major hospital systems. If you're in NYC or another metro area, you likely have good Cigna network access.

Medi-Share/Samaritan (no PPO network): You can see any provider, but you'll need to negotiate cash rates yourself or use their billing advocacy service. In New York, where provider prices are high and complex, this can require more legwork than in other states.

New York-Specific Considerations

High healthcare costs: New York has some of the highest hospital prices in the country. A single hospital night in Manhattan can run $25,000–$40,000 at list price. After PPO negotiation or cash discounts, that comes down substantially — but understand that the sharing caps ($250K for Zion, $350K for Medi-Share) exist against a high-cost backdrop.

Mental health parity: New York has strong mental health parity laws for insurers. Those laws don't apply to health sharing plans. If mental health coverage matters to you, Zion is the only health sharing plan with any meaningful outpatient therapy coverage.

No state tax penalty: New York does not have a state-level individual mandate penalty. You won't be fined for choosing health sharing.

Honest Take: Is Health Sharing Worth It in New York?

For most New Yorkers who qualify for ACA subsidies — especially at lower and middle incomes — ACA is likely the better financial choice.

For high-income, healthy New Yorkers who are paying full ACA prices, health sharing can save thousands per year. The tradeoff is giving up the regulatory protections and guaranteed issue of ACA.

The sweet spot: a healthy freelancer or self-employed New Yorker earning $65,000–$100,000/year with no significant health history. Health sharing saves real money for that person.

The wrong fit: anyone with serious pre-existing conditions, anyone who values mental health coverage, or anyone who finds ACA's regulatory protections important.

Take our quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your income, health history, and what coverage matters most to you.

Compare All Plans →