Health Sharing vs Presidio Insurance: Full Comparison for 2026

Health sharing ministries and Presidio Healthcare represent two different philosophies. Health sharing is community-based, unregulated, and typically costs $115-$268/month for individuals, but coverage is voluntary and not guaranteed. Presidio is actual regulated health insurance with guaranteed coverage, pre-existing conditions covered from day one, dental and vision included, and a Cigna PPO network with 950,000+ providers. The trade-off is cost: Presidio runs $300-$600/month for individuals. This comparison helps you decide whether savings or certainty matters more.

Zion HealthShare

50,000+ members | Founded 2017

From $185/mo

Anyone without faith requirements, best overall value

Read full review →Visit website →

Presidio Healthcare

Growing (launched 2025) members | Founded 2022

From $300/mo

Anyone needing guaranteed coverage, pre-existing conditions, regulatory protection

Read full review →Visit website →

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureHealth Sharing (Zion)Presidio Insurance
Monthly Cost (Individual)CHM $115+ / Zion $185+ / Medi-Share $227+$300-$600
TypeHealth sharing (not insurance)Regulated health insurance
Coverage GuaranteeVoluntary -- not legally guaranteedLegally guaranteed by contract
Coverage CapCHM & Zion: unlimited / Medi-Share: $250KUnlimited
Pre-Existing ConditionsZion: none / CHM: 6 mo / Medi-Share: 12 moCovered from day one (guaranteed)
NetworkZion: Cigna PPO / Others: any doctorCigna PPO (950,000+ providers)
PrescriptionsZion & Sedera: yes / CHM & Medi-Share: noIncluded
Mental HealthZion & Sedera: yes / CHM & Medi-Share: noIncluded
Dental & VisionNot includedIncluded
HSA CompatibleZion: yes / Most others: noYes

The Bottom Line

Health sharing wins on cost; Presidio wins on guaranteed coverage, pre-existing conditions, and comprehensive benefits.

Choose health sharing if

You are generally healthy, comfortable with voluntary (non-guaranteed) sharing, want to save $100-$400/month on premiums, and do not have significant pre-existing conditions. Zion HealthShare at $185/month offers the best balance of price and coverage among health sharing options.

Choose Presidio if

You need guaranteed coverage, have pre-existing conditions, want dental and vision included, need regulatory protection, or simply want the peace of mind that comes with actual insurance. At $300-$600/month it costs more, but your claims will be paid.

Read the Full Reviews

Zion HealthShare Review

Pricing, coverage details, pros and cons, and member experience.

Presidio Healthcare Review

Pricing, coverage details, pros and cons, and member experience.

CHM Review

Most affordable health sharing ministry at $115/month.

Medi-Share Review

Largest health sharing ministry with 400,000+ members.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is health sharing the same as insurance?▼
No. Health sharing is a voluntary arrangement where members share medical bills. It is not regulated by state insurance departments, and there is no legal guarantee that your bills will be shared. Presidio is actual regulated insurance with contractual coverage guarantees.
What happens if a health sharing ministry denies my claim?▼
You have no regulatory recourse. Health sharing ministries are not subject to state insurance regulations, so you cannot appeal to your state insurance commissioner. With Presidio or other regulated insurance, you can file complaints with state regulators and have legal protections.
Does Presidio cover pre-existing conditions from day one?▼
Yes. As regulated insurance, Presidio covers all pre-existing conditions from your first day of coverage with no waiting period, no phased sharing, and no exclusions. Most health sharing ministries have waiting periods of 6 to 12 months.
Can I get dental and vision through health sharing?▼
No health sharing ministry includes dental or vision coverage. Presidio's FortressPlan includes both dental and vision in addition to medical, mental health, prescriptions, and all other essential health benefits.
Is the cost difference worth it?▼
It depends on your health and risk tolerance. Saving $150-$400/month with health sharing means $1,800-$4,800/year in savings. But one denied claim for a $50,000 surgery could wipe out years of savings. If you are healthy with no pre-existing conditions and high risk tolerance, health sharing may make sense. If you need certainty, Presidio is worth the premium.

Not Sure Which Plan Is Right for You?

Take our 2-minute quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your age, health status, budget, and coverage needs.

Take the Quiz