Altrua HealthShare Review 2026
Our independent take on Altrua HealthShare — verified pricing, the real catch, and the vetted plans we'd point you to instead.
Get your personal plan match in 2 minutes
Free, no forms. Matched on your answers — not commissions.
Altrua's fine print — read this first
Altrua has a long track record (since 1996), but it also has some of the most restrictive rules in health sharing. None of it is hidden, but it is easy to miss until the moment you actually need the plan to pay.
- ✕One of the strictest pre-existing policies in the industry: a 10-year lookback, 2–5 year waiting periods, and lifetime exclusions for some conditions (e.g. MS, type-1 diabetes).
- ✕Every tier carries a lifetime sharing cap ($1M–$2M), and the lower tiers add annual caps ($150K–$250K) — most major plans have no cap at all.
- ✕Dependents are only covered to age 23 (vs. the ACA standard of 26), and prescriptions are not shared.
- ✕It is small (~25,000 members), not accredited, and not HSA-compatible.
Better-vetted options than Altrua HealthShare
If Altrua's pre-existing rules or lifetime caps are the problem, these better-rated plans are more generous on exactly those points:
Zion HealthShare
From $114/mo · Anyone without faith requirements, best overall value
Medi-Share
From $115/mo · Christian families, established community with 30+ years history
Altrua HealthShare Overview
Altrua HealthShare is a Christian health sharing ministry founded in 1996 in Bee Cave, TX with approximately 25,000 members. It offers four 'Gem' tier plans: Diamond ($356-$617/mo individual, $500 MRA), Emerald ($318-$528/mo, $1,000 MRA), Sapphire ($173-$424/mo, $1,500 MRA), and Ruby (from $136/mo for ages 0-39, $7,500 MRA). Uses First Health/PHCS network with 1M+ providers. Light Christian faith requirement with no church attendance verification. Has one of the strictest pre-existing condition policies in the industry: 10-year lookback, 2-5 year waiting periods, and some lifetime exclusions. Offers unique features like pooled office visits and SmileShare dental add-on.
Monthly Cost
From $356/mo
Coverage Cap
Unlimited annual / $2,000,000 lifetime
Pre-Existing Wait
24-60 months
Our Rating
2.8/5
The Honest Pros & Cons
What it does well
- ✓Nearly 30-year operational history (founded 1996) — one of the longest-running health sharing ministries
- ✓Four distinct plan tiers from budget Ruby to comprehensive Diamond
- ✓Pooled office visits (6 per member/year) shareable among household members
- ✓Light faith requirements — no church attendance verification
- ✓30-day free trial period with full refund option
Why we're cautious
- ✕Strict pre-existing condition policy — 10-year lookback, 2-5 year waiting periods, some lifetime exclusions
- ✕Lifetime sharing caps on all plans ($1M-$2M) limit catastrophic protection
- ✕Maternity only on Diamond and Emerald plans with $5,000 additional MRA
- ✕Dependents only covered until age 23 (younger than ACA standard of 26)
Skip the guesswork — see the plans that actually deliver.
Find My Plan (2 min) →Links to featured plans are affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This never affects our verdicts. How we make money →