Solidarity HealthShare Review 2026
Our independent take on Solidarity HealthShare — verified pricing, the real catch, and the vetted plans we'd point you to instead.
Get your personal plan match in 2 minutes
Free, no forms. Matched on your answers — not commissions.
Before you join Solidarity, know this
Being one of only two Catholic-identity plans is Solidarity's real draw. But it also carries the most unresolved member-payment complaints of any plan we cover, and we can't honestly present it as a clean pick.
- ✕An investigation by The Pillar, a Catholic news outlet, reported members whose medical bills went unpaid for months or even years.
- ✕As of 2023, Solidarity had not posted the annual financial audit that federal health-sharing disclosure rules call for.
- ✕The Better Business Bureau lists 100+ complaints, and member-review sites average roughly 1.6 out of 5 — most citing unpaid claims and bills sent to collections.
- ✕Complaints were still being filed into 2026, so these are not just early growing pains.
Better-vetted options than Solidarity HealthShare
If you want a faith-based plan with a stronger record of actually paying bills, these are the most-established options we cover:
Medi-Share
From $115/mo · Christian families, established community with 30+ years history
Zion HealthShare
From $114/mo · Anyone without faith requirements, best overall value
Solidarity HealthShare Overview
Solidarity HealthShare is a Catholic-centered health sharing ministry founded in 2016 in Tempe, AZ with approximately 55,000 members. It offers three programs: Solidarity ONE (comprehensive, available to all ages), SAVVY (young adults ages 18-29), and SHIELD (catastrophic, $12,000 AUA only). AUA (Annual Unshared Amount) tiers are $3,000/$6,000/$9,000/$12,000. Uses reference-based pricing with no provider network. The ONE plan provides best-in-class mental health coverage (unlimited counseling, medication, hospitalization) and maternity including midwives and home births. Requires Catholic or Christian faith with church attendance. Major concerns include extremely slow claims processing (6-24 months reported) and poor member satisfaction ratings. Pre-existing conditions follow a graduated ramp: not shared year 1; up to $25,000/yr in years 2-3; fully shared from year 4+.
Monthly Cost
From $67/mo
Coverage Cap
$1,000,000 per incident per year
Pre-Existing Wait
12 months
Our Rating
2.5/5
The Honest Pros & Cons
What it does well
- ✓First health sharing ministry to fully share mental health treatment (unlimited counseling, medication, hospitalization)
- ✓Comprehensive maternity coverage including hospitals, midwives, and home births
- ✓Alternative/integrative care covered (naturopathic, chiropractic, regenerative medicine)
- ✓Reference-based pricing saves 60-70% off billed charges
- ✓No age cap for membership
Why we're cautious
- ✕Extremely slow claim processing — members report 6-24 months despite stated 90-120 day timeline
- ✕Very poor member satisfaction (1.4-1.6/5 across review sites)
- ✕No traditional provider network — reference-based pricing can cause balance billing disputes
- ✕Strict faith requirements including church attendance verification
Skip the guesswork — see the plans that actually deliver.
Find My Plan (2 min) →Links to featured plans are affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This never affects our verdicts. How we make money →